But if you’re thinking about self-publishing, or wondering if you should pitch an agent, and have done even a small amount of web research, you’ve probably also seen the term “book doctor.”
Maybe you’re wondering what, precisely, is the difference?
Sometimes, people call themselves book doctors and they are really developmental editors (meaning they are equipped to help you develop the plot of your story, your characters, the big meaty bits: they will help you with the big revisions). But be careful! Because sometimes, these are folks who’ve self-pubbed, who haven’t used editors, and who don’t know their hand from their face. Sorry. I don’t like to be a crass hater, but it’s true. You don’t really have to be qualified to hang a shingle on the internet. You just have to be able to figure out WordPress or Blogger, and trust me, both are doable with any modicum of tech savvy.
Sometimes, book doctors are reasonably successful genre authors who can help you with the kinds of books they write. In my experience, traditionally published genre authors are well-informed on the demands of their particular market. They’ve read everybody like them and can probably tell you if you’ve got something sale-able on your hands.
But book doctors take the temperature of your manuscript or your ideas and asses their marketability, saleability, and they’ll be your book or proposal doula, too–they’ll be on hand to talk you through block, or help you slash darlings. They can give you tips on leveraging social media, blogging, author plarform. They can help you pick software for accounting. Maybe some of them would even make you a sandwich.
Book doctors–good ones–are the first stop before trying to publish or self-publish. Sometimes, before even developing a full draft. But make sure that the book doctor you hire is legit, and has experience with what you want to do. Ask for references or testimonials or both (if there aren’t any on their website, and even if there are). Ask for a copy of their resume or CV. Legit people won’t balk at the request or feed you a line about confidentiality agreements. They will comply happily with they information they may provide while satisfying the demands of heir confidentiality agreements.
I’ve read a bit lately about the success (or lack thereof) of self-published novels, and across discussions, blog posts, infographics, the more money a self-published author spends pre-publication, the better the book does in terms of sales. Here’s an interesting piece about Fifty Shades of Grey, and here’s something from Jamie Chavez, a happening (and experienced) independent editor.
Do You Need One?
But here’s a little quiz to check. Answer Yes or No, and tally each answer.
1. Do I have experience with writing book proposals?
2. Do I have experience with writing books?
3. Do I have experience with hiring editors?
4. Do I have a complete manuscript that I have already pitched to several agents or editors?
5. Have agents been interested?
6. Do I have a bachelor’s or master’s degree in the field of writing or in the field about which I hope to write?
7. Have I networked with any editors or agents?
9. Am I writing the book for work or to serve a specific, narrowly definable population to which I have access?
10. Have I started building my author’s platform?
7-10 Yes – You are probably okay without a book doctor, but if pitching at least 30 agents and editors doesn’t yield any results, perhaps consider a consultation with a book doctor.
4-6 Yes – You would probably benefit from a book doctor. You could probably muscle through without, but your job would be easier with one.
0-3 Yes - By all means, get on the horn this instant. Maybe even reconsider your authorial aspirations before you’ve done a little more work or research in that direction. Check out a conference in your field or a writing workshop or both.